COVID-19, privacy, and school recordings by Becky Richards

K12, Ed TECH, Superintendents, Parents

PRIVACY RIGHTS FOR CHILDREN

Dear Becky,

K12 Students Privacy rights across the nation need you help. Wish you would direct someone to take on the K12 Department of Education.

THERE ARE NO CHIEF PRIVACY OFFICERS IN K-12 EDUCATION

The big biz of spying on little kids

Google’s Apps for Education contracts with schools suffer from gaping student privacy protection loopholes. School Administrators signed a contract that does NOT protect their students from data collection for the ultimate purposes of monetization as Google represents.

ETHICS — There isn’t a single school district with a K-12 CPO.
In fact, it is still extremely rare for districts to hire even one full-time employee dedicated to privacy.

Student Privacy Bill Protection : No Parental Consent Needed for Data Mining

The Journal Report: Parents Mostly Clueless About Student Data Privacy Laws

Data broker tried to sell personal info on a million kids but didn’t tell state officials.

Where is your state “STUDENT DATA TRANSPARENCY AND SECURITY ACT”.

Who is senior-level official who is responsible for the organization’s privacy policies and data governance in your school district?

Teachers and School Districts MUST follow the law and protect children’s privacy!!!

Statewide Longitudinal Data Systems, or SLDS.
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/slds/
That marked the entrance of big data into education, enabled by the leaps forward in the ability to store and process information on remote servers “in the cloud.”

Rebecca “Becky” Richards 

first civil liberties and privacy officer (CLPO).
NSA Civil Liberties and Privacy Director — BIO PDF

COVID-19, privacy, and school recordings

by Becky Richards

Imagine being the school administrator when you realize that one of your student’s parents is in charge of privacy at the NSA and isn’t happy with your video recording policies for remote learning.

https://iapp.org/about/person/0011a00000DlQcSAAV

Rebecca “Becky” Richards joined the National Security Agency as its first Director of Civil Liberties and Privacy in February 2014. Her primary job is to provide expert advice to the Director and oversee NSA’s civil liberties and privacy activities. She is also responsible for developing measures to further strengthen NSA’s privacy and civil liberties protection.

There had been a short discussion of recording classes followed by an even shorter discussion of the fact that the school is in a two-party consent state. So I didn’t think much more of the discussion until this consent to record showed up quietly the Friday of Labor Day weekend, taunting me, poking at me, gnawing at me and eventually just outright leading me to the outrage that someone thought it was a good idea to write a legally compliant consent that had a threat at the end.

So, I decided to apply my day job as the civil liberties and privacy officer at the U.S. National Security Agency to my parenting job. Though not something I had expected, it seemed to me this was an important teachable moment for the school and kids about how to make thoughtful choices for privacy, civil liberties and teaching.

There may be times particularly with older children or adults during which recording the sessions makes sense, but when we are working with K-8 that needs are necessarily different. So I started a conversation with my school and refused to sign the consent.

I expressed concerns that the consent was very broad and protective of the institution but had no protections in place for the children. There were no stated controls on who would use the recordings or why they were being done beyond operational uses and instances when a child was having a one-on-one conversation with a teacher and no parent was available.

Classes were not recorded when they were in person, so why should they be now? Just because you can, does not mean you should. If there was a benefit to this, why did not we do it earlier during in-person classes?

What are the benefits of recording a class? Are they available for students and parents at a later date, if the material wasn’t understood, more review was needed or a child was out of class? Perhaps they are available for administration to review to improve teaching and/or provide feedback on the teaching or accountability for one-on-one meetings between the child and the teacher.

What are the risks of recording a class? Children may be less willing to participate, children become acclimated to always being recorded (or surveilled), a misstep in class is now caught on camera and available for all to see rather than it being a one-time misstep. Without proper access controls, those not normally in the class could access the sessions and take teaching and interactions out of context. These are “windows” into families’ private lives, into our homes, and potentially capturing others collaterally having nothing to do with the school. If it was just the teacher and audio of the students, that would be less intrusive but still concerning.

And alas, I always have to ask, “Is it muted?” Which is concerning, given I’m asking an 11-year-old if it is OK to talk in my own house. What precedent are we setting for our children for acceptable behavior?

While cellphones, cameras and recordings seem to be pervasive, they are not the full solution to concerns with what is happening in a school, class or society. They are one piece of the puzzle, and we need to treat them as such.

I appreciate that perhaps there wasn’t time to think through how these videos will be used, but it is incumbent upon the school to have this all thought through before starting the recordings. So I decided to provide them input on how they could use this policy as an opportunity to build trust through civil liberties and privacy protections and be more transparent.  

Here are some of the examples of improved civil liberties and privacy protections I offered, which you may find helpful if you are finding that your kids’ classes are being recorded:

  • Videos are available for a shorter time (say one week) so that children in the class can review them in case they missed the class.
  • Only families who have children in the class can view the videos rather than the entire school.
  • If there is a one-on-one meeting with a child, perhaps this is recorded and then, upon review by the family, is deleted rather than being kept for long periods of time.
  • No recordings should be done for religious activities.
  • Clearly written notices describing the practices that will be taking place.

The school has been listening since I approached them and were very quick to respond that their intention wasn’t to record everything or surveil the students, but none of that was in the policy — it only protected the school and told parents that we couldn’t use the recordings for any purposes at all.

After a lengthy discussion with the school, they agreed to issue a policy that teachers will only record themselves, no student interactions; one-on-one interactions without a parent will be recorded and retained for seven days, and the parent will be asked to review to ensure there is no concerning behavior; no religious activities will be recorded; any recordings of parent meeting will start with a notification that the event is being recorded, and individuals should turn off their cameras if they do not wish to be recorded. This creates good civil liberties and privacy protections and transparency about the policy for all.

As we concluded the call, our head of school noted she appreciated the conversation and the outcome, but this was not anything covered in her training to be a teacher or school administrator.

It seems like it is time to start adding these to the curriculum for everyone.

Rebecca Richards is the director of civil liberties and privacy at the U.S. National Security Agency.

 

IAPP @PrivacyPros
We are the #IAPP, your global #privacy community & resource. Tweets generated from the IAPP social media team. For breaking news, follow

Portsmouth, NH iapp.org

Rebecca Richards, CIPP/G, CIPP/US

U.S. National Security Agency
Director, Civil Liberties, Privacy, and Transparency Office

Educational CyberPlayground® Nethappenings 4-9-20 Articles and Videos

www.edu-cyberpg.com#SchoolShooting #intelligence #Security #China #CCP #2025 #coronavirus #bailouts #Harvard #Yale #usc#testicularCancer #antiviralSpray #ChairmanMao #Compensation #Trump #Pirate #Fascist #Graft #VOTE #Fraud #TrumpHotel #CoronavirusBailout #PRIVACY #testicularDamage #Seman #Kusher #Supply-Chain #GOP #DeVos #RichestPastors #CowboyMuseum #Amazon #AntiTrust #Patriot

1. I’m a whole person, not a robot
2. I will always speak truth to power, party be damned
3. I will use my platform for social good
4. The economy should remain shut down until Steve Mnuchin can live for 10 weeks on $1,200.

“We don’t have nearly enough technological optimism in our popular culture (movies etc). Everything is dystopias. This unbalance is deeply harmful. We need to be thinking about not just the bad we need to avoid but also the good we should be striving for. If people created technologies that inspired creatives to see visions of things other than dystopias then maybe they would write about them.
Let’s be clear that treatments are more expensive than vaccines since it means you entered the healthcare system with symptoms and a vaccine is prophylactic so you don’t incur additional healthcare costs.
The conspiracy then continues to suggest that It’s not that people are being stupid about quarantine, but that they are infected with COVID-19 and are being compelled by neurological symptoms to spread the virus to as many people as possible. It’s outside of their control.” ~ anon

“Want to re-open the economy? I have sourced COVID-19 15 minute test kits from European providers. Minimum lot of 10,000. Municipalities, health care providers, and corporations, only. I will not sell to private individuals. Otherwise, slide into my DMs for more info.”
https://twitter.com/BryceWeiner/status/1250903028904808448

#SchoolShooting
Last month was the first March without a school shooting in the United States since 2002.
Congrats everyone! We defeated school shootings and all it took was closing every school in America.
For this years graduating seniors, this is the first March in their lifetimes without a shooting.

#Compensation

#AntiTrustLaw

Why laws needed to break up monopoly
#Amazon to suspend delivery service competing with UPS, FedEx
Amazon.com Inc will suspend a delivery service that aims to compete with UPS and FedEx in the United States.

#CHINA

HongKong #Patriot

Martin Lee, founder of the Hong Kong Democratic Party, was arrested today together with many of #HongKong’s most prominent citizens. Martin is the elder statesman of Hong Kong democracy.

HIGHER EDUCATION CORRUPTION

#USC
University of Southern CA
Hot Pockets Heiress Michelle Janavs Sentenced to 5 Months Imprisonment in College Admissions Scam
Janavs, whose family developed the (unhealthy) microwaveable snack before selling their company, which is now owned by Nestlé, had earlier pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering in the far-reaching college admissions scandal.

#Harvard

#YALE
Students call for “universal pass”
The coalition is advocating for a system where students would receive credit for every class — including distributional requirements — and receive a “P” instead of a letter grade on their transcripts.
“Universal pass is just a very fair grading system,” Huang said. “People come from different circumstances.” Arguments in favor of universal pass center on the idea that campus is an equalizer.

#Trump #Fraud #Graft #VOTE

3/13/2020 No Test Trump “I don’t take responsibility at all.” ~ Trump

Trump’s Insincere Sincerity
Hello chinese corona virus
Darling you rook marvelous
You know id rather look good than feel good
You know who you are

Romans Used to Ward Off Sickness With Flying Penis Amulets

#Intelligence

#VOTE

#Trump #Fraud #Graft

A president unfit for a pandemic – The Boston Globe

Don’t believe the numbers you see‘: Johns Hopkins professor says up to 500,000 Americans have coronavirus

#Fascist

Mr Trump said: “When somebody is the president of the United States, the authority is total.
“It’s total. The governors know that.”
He added: “That being said, we’re going to work with the states.”

Trump is a traitor and his crime family is the enemy.

Just a reminder that our current president has been hit by the Stone Cold Stunner

#SupplyChaiN #supply-chain #PIRATE

Illinois reportedly organized secret flights bringing masks from China
GOVERNMENT PIRACY Tell America it’s on its own, then intervene to pirate PPE shipments. #TrumpCrimeFamily #TrumpCrimesCommission

The #Trump administration proposed in its fiscal year 2019 budget to cut funding for the CDC by 20 percent, from $7.2 billion to $5.7 billion. If passed by Congress, that would bring the CDC back to its lowest level of funding since 2003.

The drug industry is showing that even in a crisis, it can use its influence in Washington to fight off efforts to cut into its profits. Industry lobbyists successfully blocked attempts this week to include language in the $8.3 billion emergency coronavirus spending bill that would have threatened intellectual property rights for any vaccines and treatments the government decides are priced unfairly.

Colorado Rep. Diana DeGette Believes Trump Gifting Ventilators to Political Allies

#Coronavirus: Democrats demand details of Jared Kushner’s involvement in #Supply chain

****Nobody***** is talking about this
—–>In Pursuit of #PPE<——

As a chief physician executive, I rarely get involved in my health system’s supply-chain activities. The Covid-19 pandemic has changed that. Protecting our caregivers is essential so that these talented professionals can safely provide compassionate care to our patients. Yet we continue to be stymied by a lack of personal protective equipment (PPE), and the cavalry does not appear to be coming.

#PRIVACY

Edward Snowden On Trump, Privacy, And Threats To Democracy

This Small Company Is Turning Utah Into a Surveillance Panopticon

#GOP THE PRO LIFE PARTY THAT KILLS YOU WHEN THEY WANT MONEY

QUESTION: Who or which business stands to make the most money if there aren’t any tests?

A Pandemic Killed Trump’s Grandpa. This One Could Destroy His Presidency.

Brazil: Judge bans missionaries from indigenous reserve over Covid-19 fears #Jesus

LDS Church discloses the $37.8 billion stock portfolio of its biggest investment fund

A #DeVos-Linked Group Promoted the Right-Wing “Operation Gridlock” Tantrum in Michigan

Trump’s seditious “LIBERATE” tweets were on the same date as Virginia’s secession.

Asked about the crowded beaches in #Florida, Dr. Birx replies: “I am not going to second judge” the county health officials there.

No, Governor DeSantis, that is not how masks work

Repuglican Bob Brooks PA must have learned to do it from DeSantis JPG

The Trump administration’s failure

Sixty-six senators are over age 60 — two-thirds of the body — with more than a quarter over 70. The average age of House members is 57.6 years, according to the Congressional Research Service.

#Trump is killing his own supporters’even White House insiders know it

US coronavirus testing needs to go up by 350,000 per day, researchers say

Scant testing in US migration system risks spreading virus The Trump administration’s failure to test all but a small percentage of detained immigrants

The richest Pastors in America: Total: $1.06
Total donated to COVID-19 assistance $0.00
Kenneth Copeland $760M Pat Robertson $100M Benny Hinn $60M Joel Osteen $40M Credulous Dollar $27M Rick Warren $25M Franklin Graham $25M T.D. Jakes $18M Joyce Meyer $8M
“President George W. Bush in 2005: “There is no pandemic flu in our country or in the world at this time. But if we wait for a pandemic to appear, it will be too late to prepare. And one day many lives could be needlessly lost because we failed to act today. Do you realize what a colossal fuckup you need to be to make George W. Bush look like a hero of science?

4/6/2020 Eight states, all of them with Republican governors, have yet to order residents to stay home: Arkansas, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Carolina, South Dakota, Utah and Wyoming. Georgia, which has recorded 6,600 cases and more than 200 deaths, ordered residents to stay home but then allowed some beaches to reopen.
To be clear, the state of Florida never closed the beaches along its 1,350 miles (2,173 kilometers) of shoreline, except in South Florida — a hot spot for coronavirus infections. Decisions on beach closures have been left in the hands of local governments, and when Gov. Ron DeSantis issued a “safer at home” order on April 1, he specifically said walking, running and swimming were essential activities.
After that order, Volusia County, home to the famed Daytona Beach, opened its beaches with restrictions on April 4. While exercise was allowed, beach volleyball wasn’t.

@jack loves the bitcoin and now he has a bank

The National #Cowboy Museum Put Their Head Of Security In Charge Of Twitter Account
Whatever job or industry you might be in, chances are you’ve experienced performing a duty outside your job description. Depending on the nature of the duty, the experience can either be exhausting or exciting. Luckily, it is the latter for Tim Send, head of security at the National Cowboy Museum in Oklahoma. Apparently, the museum has been generating quite a buzz online for putting Send in charge of their social media accounts.

Sportsbooks are dark and odds are long in Las Vegas
Nobody would have given odds on this.
Inside the glittering casinos that line the Las Vegas Strip

Sunlight destroys virus quickly, new govt. tests find, but experts say pandemic could last through summer

– MSNBC Web Picks 11/1999 : The Educational CyberPlayground, Inc.®: A helpful resource to teachers, parents, librarians, home schoolers and even those with little or no on-line experience, to use the Internet effectively to aid teaching.

– USA Today BEST BETS AWARD FOR EDUCATORS  01-09-1999 The Educational CyberPlayground, Inc.® provides teachers, parents, librarians, home schoolers and regular folks a “webliography” of links to educational resources in a wide range of subjects. With a cool choice of site maps to browse from.

– USA TODAY gives the  The Educational CyberPlayground, Inc.® their HOT SITE AWARD January 10, 2000

The Educational CyberPlayground, Inc.® New York Times Site Of The Day 5/2000

The Educational CyberPlayground, Inc.® Macworld High-Quality Education on the Web 50 of the Best Sites and A IS FOR ART 2000

Top 5 Voted The Most Evil Companies in Tech

Top 5 worst companies out of 30

BREAK THEM UP – BREAK THEM UP – BREAK THEM UP

#1 Amazon  Jeff Bezos
#2 Facebook Mark Zuckerberg
#3  Alphabet Sundar Pichai
#4 Palantir Technologies  Alex Karp
# 5 Uber Dara Khosrowshahi

by @felixsalmon
 @hypervisible
 @sivavaid
 @merbroussard
 @matthewstoller
 @dgolumbia
 & others

2020 birthdays

2020 birthdays

Lyft: 8
Snapchat: 9
Instagram: 10
Uber: 11
Twitter: 14
Reddit: 15
YouTube: 15
Facebook: 16
Tesla: 17
Google: 22
Mozilla: 22
Netflix: 23
Amazon: 26
Qualcomm: 35
Apple: 44
Microsoft: 45
AMD: 51
Intel: 52
Sony: 74
HP: 81
Samsung: 82
Disney: 97
IBM: 109
Nintendo: 131