MPAA & RIAA: If People Can Sell Foreign Purchased Content Without Paying Us Again, US Economy May Collapse

FIRST SALE RIGHTS: Here’s the real problem: the RIAA and MPAA want to have their cake and eat it too. If products bought abroad and then imported into the US don’t get first sale rights, then it seems only reasonable that they shouldn’t get US copyright protection either.

MPAA & RIAA: If People Can Sell Foreign Purchased Content Without Paying Us Again, US Economy May Collapse

We’ve written a few times about the upcoming Kirtsaeng case before the Supreme Court concerning first sale rights. If you don’t recall, the 2nd Circuit appears to have wiped out the first sale doctrine for content purchased outside the country that you want to resell within the US. As we noted, there are significant worries about how such a ruling could really harm innovation. At issue was a guy who bought textbooks abroad and resold them in the US (for less than the cover price that the publishers wanted students to buy). The courts basically found that because the textbooks were made outside the US, they weren’t “lawfully made under this title,” which is some clumsy phrasing that’s at issue here.
Of course, thanks to our copyright maximalism, under Kirtsaeng, if a product is made outside the US and then imported, US copyright law appears to apply to almost everything that’s copyrightable… except that first sale rights go away. If that seems dangerous, you get a sense of how important the Supreme Court’s ruling in Kirtsaeng can be, hopefully by bringing back some sanity, and showing that if you legally purchase some digital content you have the right to resell it.
It appears that the RIAA and MPAA are pretty scared about this possibility. They’ve filed quite the amicus brief in the case claiming that buying goods overseas and selling them in the US is the equivalent of piracy. No joke:

Copyright protection is essential to the health of the motion picture and music industries and the U.S. economy as a whole. Like the sale of “pirated” copies, unauthorized importation of copies of protected works made overseas and intended only for sale in a foreign market can undercut or eliminate the economic benefit that Congress intended to provide under the Copyright Act.

Oh, and it gets worse . . . .
Movies in the Classroom. MPAA Film Censorship Secret Cartel rates films for the past 80 years. Motion Picture Association of America rates films.
K12 PUBLIC EDUCATION – Truth and Reality How the World Really Works.
Preservation vs. Copyright
Organisations like the RIAA and MPAA, as well as its promoters, have no interest in promoting the arts and sciences – our learning has been locked up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *